I didn't like him very much in his Malice Mizer days though that is actually more due to their over the top make up and so on, and probably a take off from my intense dislike of Mana (Mana freaks me). And after that was a period where in a lot of pictures he looked as if he were eternally in love with himself - ie the ultimate narcist - but I later found out that was more due to his then photographer liking a certain style (I'm glad he got rid of that guy).
But I think the reason people are negayive about him is really largelyin his looks: he doesn't look "typically" Japanese, so he must have had surgery. He's beautiful for a man, so he must be gay. He's beautiful, so he can't be intelligent or a good musican or whatever. All the usual cliches.
For me, it's lead me to make someone listen to one of his songs - admittedly the latter ones, of the last 2 - 3 years - WITHOUT telling them who it is. An amazing number will say they'll like the voice or the music or both and then are totally stunned when I tell them "that's Gackt" because they never even bothered to LISTEN to his music, even while they were dissing him.
(Wow this topic hasn't been posted on in a long time. :shock:
As far as Gackt's timeline, I usually like his Malice Mizer stuff better XD Although I think that is BECAUSE of their visual style.
And the listening without knowing it thing... I have done that with X, Gackt and L'Arc~en~Ciel, and I love the results it produces! Because everyone has these stereotypes in mind, with the whole "oh it's foreign" thing, or the looks, the rumors, the clichés... drives me crazy, I just have to break them!
And regarding the "must be gay"... I have never seen a Japanese artist's orientation discussed publicly like artists in America. Is it just a respect thing, or is there a reason behind this?
Also:
Well, I remember some of the things Yoshiki was called way back when . . .
I am usually a peaceful person but then I wanted to punch a few faces, occassionally.
I have never heard this discussed either. May I ask what happened? (PM is fine if you prefer
)
Lastly, I do adore Gackt Job! And I agree, Gackt and You are incredibly cute together. It's hard for me to decide my favorite Gackt song, because there are many I like! But I LOVE Vanilla. I always have. And I also like Saikai~story~ and The Last Song, and White Eyes....I better stop before I list them all! :oops:
Sorry for the long post - it was a lot to reply to.