thnkx for quoting me
And hey dont get me wrong Joey Jordison is a good drummer but you cant compare his drumming style to Yoshiki's.
Joey just sits and moves his arms. His drums sticks re light as hell because professional drummers uses light sticks so they can do the fills faster and easier.
Yoshiki sits, moves his whole body and plays And his sticks are heavier so you can hear the drum more loud and powerful.
And while Yoshiki moves like hell he hurts himself... And that's NOT good even if it looks fun and all that shit.
These "I know because that's the way feel about this matter"- comments really annoy me...
I can tell you that don't know what you're talking about. What on earth has the drumstick weight got to do with anything? Joey BTW uses ALUMINIUM drumsticks which are NOT lighter that Yoshiki's. I haven't played with Yoshiki's sticks but I've tried Joey's and they where not as light as you claim them to be. Yoshiki's, if I remember correctly, are just standard american hickory which is quite light compared to aluminium sticks. So their goes your "light-sticks-theory".
"And his sticks are heavier so you can hear the drum more loud and powerful." Could it be possible that Yoshiki's drums are bigger in size, because that is a FACT, and they produce a deeper and bigger sound than Joey's smaller drums? On the 80's when Yoshiki bought his drums the standard drumsizes where bigger than nowadays.
"His drums sticks re light as hell because professional drummers uses light sticks so they can do the fills faster and easier." Can you really prove this? Jazz drummers usually use those light-as-hell sticks where as metal drummers choose those longer, heavier and harder ones. Trust me. I KNOW! *raises one's hand to say that is a drummer himself*
Joey has played in a jazz before Slipknot so, I know this, he can do much MUCH more. But Slipknot doesn't need anything more. Why should he play something more? C'mon, people haven't you REALLY listened to X's drumlines? It's the same freaking power metal beat that you hear one EVERY single metal album out there!! OK, Yoshiki's drumfills are veeery tricky though BUT
so are Joey's!If you ask me, I have to say that it's not about "art" or "speed" or anything like it. This conversation is all about the matter that we know as
THE HALO EFFECT!We like X. Not everyone of us like Slipknot. "Slipknot suck hariy donkey arseholes", "no no no dont get me wrong i know that slipknot is a load of trash and there music is complete bullshit in my opinion"... And just because one doesn't like Slipknot = Joey is not as good as Yoshiki.
If I'd say that Joey has more soul in his playing than Yoshiki does. Am I wrong? It's my opinion right? "Art" and "soul" etc. are words that are totally subjective. One cannot say that the other one is wrong when saying f.ex "Joey has more sould in playing than Yoshiki does".
And if we can't compare Yoshiki and Joey, then who can we compare? I can give you guys THOUSANDS of technically skilled drummers who wipe the floor with both Joey AND Yoshiki. For example this guy called
Mike Mangini is way better technically than Yoshiki and Joey put together and I see the SOUL in his playing. Can you really tell me that I'm wrong by saying that?